How To Pit Olives | Pitting Olives: The Perfect Method

Have you ever tried pitting olives at home and thought, “There’s gotta be an easier way!”? Yeah, me too. Olives are so versatile—whether you’re tossing them into a salad, adding them to pizza, or blending them into a tapenade. But let me tell you, getting those little pits out can be a real challenge if you don’t know what you’re doing.

I remember the first time I tried to pit olives for my family. I was rushing to make a quick pasta dinner, and I had a jar of whole olives that needed to be pitted. I grabbed a knife and tried to cut around the pit, but it was a total disaster. I ended up with squashed olives and pits flying everywhere! My kitchen was a mess, and dinner took way longer than it should have. My kids were sitting at the table like, “Mom, is everything okay?” Spoiler alert: it wasn’t.

After that chaotic dinner, I knew I had to figure out a better way to pit olives. Once I learned the proper method, it was such a game-changer. Now, pitting olives is a breeze, and it makes a huge difference in how fresh and flavorful they taste in our meals. Plus, it saves me from buying those pre-pitted ones that never seem as good. If you love cooking with olives as much as I do, learning how to pit them at home is definitely worth it!

Why Pit Your Own Olives?

Okay, so you might be wondering, “Why should I even bother pitting my own olives when I can just buy the pre-pitted ones?” Well, let me tell you, there’s a huge difference in taste and quality when you do it yourself.

First off, pitting your own olives means fresher taste. Those pre-pitted olives sitting in a jar? They just don’t have the same flavor as the ones you pit yourself. Once the pit is removed, the olive loses some of its natural oils, and with that, a lot of its rich, briny taste. So when you pit your own, you’re getting all that amazing olive flavor. Trust me, you’ll taste the difference in your dishes—whether it’s in a salad, on a pizza, or even just snacking on them.

Another great reason is that you can choose higher-quality whole olives. When you buy pre-pitted, you’re stuck with whatever type they use, and let’s be honest, it’s usually the cheaper kind. By pitting your own, you can pick the best olives, whether it’s fancy Castelvetranos or those delicious kalamata ones.

Also, it’s way more economical in the long run. Whole olives are often cheaper than the pre-pitted ones, and you get more bang for your buck. I’ve found that buying a jar of whole olives lasts longer, and I don’t feel like I’m wasting money on bland, squished olives that aren’t as fresh.

Lastly, you get a wider variety to choose from. Some of the best olive varieties only come whole, which means you can’t even enjoy them unless you know how to pit them yourself. Imagine the possibilities—there’s so many flavors and textures to explore when you’re pitting your own! Plus, it’s kinda satisfying once you get the hang of it.

So yeah, pitting your own olives takes a little bit of effort, but the benefits totally make it worth it.

The Tools You Need to Pit Olives

Alright, let’s talk about the tools you’ll need to pit olives. Now, you don’t need anything fancy, but having the right tools can definitely make things easier.

First up, there’s the olive pitter tool. It’s not a must-have, but if you’re serious about pitting olives (like if you cook with them a lot), this little gadget is super helpful. It’s designed to get the pit out in one clean motion without crushing the olive. Think of it like a cherry pitter but for olives! I didn’t own one for years, but once I finally got one, I was like, “Where has this been all my life?”

But let’s be real—most of us don’t have an olive pitter just lying around. So, the next best thing is a chef’s knife or small paring knife. You can easily pit olives with just a knife by placing the olive on a sturdy cutting board and pressing down with the flat side of the knife. The pit pops right out, and you’re good to go. This is my go-to when I’m in a hurry. To be honest, I’ve used whatever knife is closest to me—because, you know, when you’re rushing to get dinner on the table, you’re not exactly thinking about the “right” tool.

And don’t forget to have a small bowl for the pits. I’ve made the mistake of just pushing the pits to the side and then spent way too much time cleaning them off the counter. Having a designated bowl keeps things tidy, especially when you’re working with a big batch of olives.

So, whether you’re using an olive pitter or just grabbing the nearest knife (like I usually do!), these basic tools will help you get the job done without too much hassle.

Step-by-Step Method On How To Pit Olives Using Different Methods

There are a few ways to pit olives, and trust me, you don’t need to be a pro to get it done. Depending on how many olives you’re pitting or what tools you have on hand, you can choose the method that works best for you. Let’s break it down!

Method 1: How to Pit Olives Using an Olive Pitter

If you’ve got an olive pitter, this is the easiest and fastest way, especially when you’re dealing with a large batch of olives. Here’s how you do it:

1. Grab your olive pitter and place the olive in the slot where the pit will be pushed through.
2. Squeeze the handle gently, and the pit should pop right out, leaving the olive mostly intact.
3. Repeat the process until all your olives are pitted.

This tool is a lifesaver when I’m prepping for a big family meal. I love using this method when making Mediterranean dishes, like my go-to Greek salad or olive tapenade. It’s quick, efficient, and great if you’re dealing with a lot of olives. Plus, you don’t end up squishing the olives too much, so they still look pretty on the plate!

Method 2: How to Pit Olives Using a Knife

Now, if you don’t have an olive pitter (and let’s be honest, most of us don’t), a knife works just fine. Here’s how to pit olives using a chef’s knife or even a small paring knife:

1. Place the olive on a cutting board. You want it on a flat, sturdy surface.
2. Hold the knife flat and gently press down on the olive until the pit starts to loosen.
3. Pull the pit out with your fingers or use the knife to nudge it out.

This is perfect for smaller batches or when you just need a handful of olives. It’s quick, and you don’t need any special tools. I use this method all the time when I’m rushing to get dinner on the table and can’t be bothered to dig through my drawers for a pitter. And hey, if you squish an olive or two, no big deal—it still tastes great!

Method 3: How to Pit Olives By Hand-Squeezing

For softer olives like kalamata or black olives, you can actually just use your hands. This method is a little messier, but it works, especially when you’re not worried about keeping the olives perfectly intact.

1. Take the olive in your hand and gently squeeze it until the pit pops out.
2. You might need to use your fingers to help pull the pit out if it’s being stubborn.

I usually end up using this method when I’m pitting just a few olives for a snack or a quick dish. It’s not the prettiest method, and yes, your hands will get a bit messy, but it’s super quick. And sometimes, that’s all that matters when you’re trying to juggle making dinner and dealing with kids asking, “Is dinner ready yet?”

So whether you’re using a pitter, a knife, or just your hands, there’s a method that’ll work for you depending on what you have at home. Just pick what feels easiest in the moment—trust me, I’ve tried them all!

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Pitting Olives

Alright, even though pitting olives is pretty straightforward, there are a few mistakes that can make things trickier (and messier). Trust me, I’ve been there!

One big mistake is crushing the olive too hard. I’ve done this way too many times, especially when I was first learning. You get so focused on getting the pit out that you press too hard, and before you know it, the olive is totally squished, and you’ve lost half the flesh. The trick is to use just enough pressure to loosen the pit without completely flattening the olive. It takes a bit of practice, but once you get the feel for it, you’ll be pitting olives like a pro.

Another common mistake is using the wrong tool or too much force. I used to grab whatever knife was closest, and sometimes it was way too big or just not right for the job. If you’re using a chef’s knife, make sure it’s the flat side pressing down, not the sharp edge (been there, done that!). And if you’re hand-squeezing, go easy—you don’t need to squeeze like you’re trying to crush a rock.

Lastly, not having a clean surface can lead to a big mess. I’ve made the mistake of trying to pit olives on a cluttered countertop, and pits ended up rolling everywhere. Now I always make sure I have a clean cutting board and a small bowl ready for the pits. It makes the whole process smoother and saves me from cleaning up random olive bits from all over the kitchen later.

So, avoid these mistakes, and you’ll have perfectly pitted olives without all the fuss. And hey, even if you do squish a few, it’s all part of the learning process—plus, they still taste amazing!

How To Use Pitted Olives in Recipes

Once you’ve got those olives pitted and ready to go, the fun really begins! There are so many ways to use them, and I’ve found they can add so much flavor to even the simplest meals. Here are some of my favorite ways to use pitted olives, whether I’m whipping up a quick dinner or trying to impress the family with something new:

1. Mediterranean Salad – Toss pitted olives into a fresh salad with cucumbers, tomatoes, red onion, and feta cheese. Drizzle some olive oil and a splash of lemon juice, and you’ve got an easy, flavorful side dish that complements almost any meal. My kids even eat this up, and they’re not always the biggest salad fans!
2. Homemade Pizza – On pizza night, I always add pitted olives on top of our homemade pizzas. You can go classic with tomato sauce and mozzarella, or try something different like an olive, spinach, and goat cheese combo. The olives give it that salty, tangy flavor that’s so good.
3. Pasta with Olive and Tomato Sauce – Stir pitted olives into your favorite tomato sauce and let it simmer for a while to blend the flavors. Toss the sauce with spaghetti or penne and top with parmesan. It’s a simple dinner but packed with flavor. When I’m in a hurry, this dish always saves the day.
4. Olive Tapenade – Blend pitted olives with garlic, olive oil, and a bit of lemon juice to make a quick tapenade. Spread it on crackers or baguette slices for an easy appetizer. I usually make this for gatherings, and it’s always a hit with friends and family—plus, it takes just a few minutes to throw together.
5. Olive-Stuffed Chicken – For a special dinner, try stuffing chicken breasts with a mix of chopped pitted olives, feta, and herbs. Bake it until the chicken is cooked through, and serve with roasted vegetables or rice. This dish looks fancy but is super easy to make. My kids love the cheesy, briny filling!
6. Vegetable Casserole with Olives – Mix pitted olives into a veggie casserole with zucchini, cherry tomatoes, and bell peppers. Top with breadcrumbs and bake until everything is golden and bubbly. The olives add a savory depth to the dish that makes it feel a little more special, even on a busy weeknight.
7. Hummus Wrap with Olives – Spread hummus on a wrap, add some pitted olives, cucumber slices, and spinach, then roll it up for a quick, healthy lunch. This is one of my go-to meals when I need something fast but still filling. The olives give the wrap a nice salty kick!
8. Olive and Cheese Skewers – For a fun snack or appetizer, skewer pitted olives with chunks of cheese (cheddar or mozzarella work great) and cherry tomatoes. It’s a quick and easy way to use up ingredients, and the kids love assembling these themselves.
9. Olive and Herb Soup – Add pitted olives to a hearty vegetable or chicken soup for a burst of flavor. I love adding them to a Mediterranean-style soup with carrots, celery, and chickpeas. It’s warm, comforting, and the olives give it that extra something special.
10. Olive Bread – If you’re baking bread at home, try kneading some chopped pitted olives into the dough. It adds a savory, briny flavor that’s perfect for serving alongside soups or salads. I make a simple olive flatbread sometimes, and it’s gone in minutes once it hits the table!

Using pitted olives in these recipes not only brings extra flavor but makes even simple meals feel a bit more gourmet. They’re one of those ingredients that I always keep stocked because they can easily elevate so many dishes!

How to Store Pitted Olives

Once you’ve pitted your olives, you want to store them properly to keep them fresh and flavorful. Here’s how I like to store home-pitted olives to make sure they last as long as possible (and trust me, with three kids, they go fast, but it’s always nice to have some on hand for recipes!).

1. In an Airtight Container – After pitting the olives, I transfer them into an airtight container. You want to make sure it’s sealed well so they don’t dry out. I’ve made the mistake of just covering them with plastic wrap, and they didn’t stay as fresh. An airtight container is definitely the way to go!
2. Add Brine or Olive Oil – To keep the olives moist and flavorful, pour a bit of olive brine or even plain olive oil over them before sealing the container. This helps preserve them longer and keeps that rich, olive taste intact. Plus, it makes them ready to use in recipes right out of the fridge!
3. Refrigerate Immediately – Once they’re in a container with brine or oil, pop them in the fridge. Pitted olives can last up to two weeks in the refrigerator, but in my house, they’re usually gone much sooner because I toss them into everything from salads to pasta dishes.
4. Freeze for Long-Term Storage – If you’re not planning to use the olives within a couple of weeks, you can freeze them! Just make sure to drain them from any brine or oil, pat them dry, and place them in a freezer-safe bag or container. They’ll last up to six months in the freezer. I love freezing olives because when I need them, I can just thaw a few at a time without wasting any.
5. Label and Date Your Container – This might sound a little extra, but labeling and dating your container helps you keep track of when you pitted and stored the olives. I’ve definitely forgotten about olives in the fridge before and wondered, “Are these still good?” A quick label can save you from second-guessing later.
6. Check for Freshness Before Using – Always give your stored olives a quick sniff and look before using them. If they smell off or have a weird texture, it’s better to toss them. I hate wasting food, but better safe than sorry!

By following these simple storage tips, you can enjoy your home-pitted olives for longer, and they’ll stay fresh and ready for all your favorite recipes! It’s so nice to have them prepped and waiting in the fridge when I need them for a quick salad or a tasty snack.

Frequently Asked Questions